Consultation Question 33
Comment
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 25166
Received: 23/03/2021
Respondent: Home Builders Federation
This policy requires affordable housing contributions on all major residential development, it sets different targets based on zones and whether the site is PDL or greenfield. The affordable housing requirement ranges from 10% in Inner Bradford and Keighley to 40% on greenfield sites in Wharfedale. The policy goes on to suggest that the tenure mix will be 65% for affordable rent and 35% affordable home ownership products. It also states that in line with national policy at least 10% of the overall affordable housing contribution from a site should be available for affordable home ownership.
The Financial Viability Assessment Report sets out the latest viability position. It highlights that there are viability issues in in the lower and lower medium value zones and recommends a reduced affordable housing requirement in these areas. For the lower zones the Assessment recommends reducing the affordable housing requirement to nothing, although it does suggest that it may be possible to set the level at 10% in line with the NPPF and consider proactive interventions in the market to support delivery. It is not apparent from the policy what proactive interventions the Council proposes.
The HBF notes that the NPPF states that where major development involving the provision of housing is proposed, planning policies should expect at least 10% of the homes to be available for affordable home ownership, unless this would exceed the level of affordable housing required in the area. The HBF are concerned this has been misinterpreted by the Council. The 10% affordable home ownership is a proportion of the overall number of homes provided, not from the affordable housing contribution. As such if the Council is following the recommendation from the Viability Assessment in terms of the lower value areas the affordable housing provision from these areas should be only in the form of affordable home ownership homes. The HBF considers that the Council should also give further consideration of this NPPF requirement in relation to the tenure split proposed across other areas too. As at present it would not be possible to provide both the NPPF 10% affordable home ownership homes and the meet the proposed affordable housing split set in the policy.
The HBF supports the need to address the affordable housing requirements of the borough. The NPPF is, however, clear that the derivation of affordable housing policies must not only take account of need but also viability and deliverability. The Council should be mindful that it is unrealistic to negotiate every site on a one-by-one basis because the base-line aspiration of a policy or combination of policies is set too high as this will jeopardise future housing delivery.
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 25199
Received: 23/03/2021
Respondent: Stephen Radcliffe
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 25228
Received: 23/03/2021
Respondent: Denise Stanford
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 25440
Received: 23/03/2021
Respondent: Rebecca Stokes
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 25489
Received: 23/03/2021
Respondent: Mary Pawson
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 25718
Received: 24/03/2021
Respondent: Mrs Penny Price
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 25747
Received: 24/03/2021
Respondent: Mrs Sue Bell
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 25776
Received: 24/03/2021
Respondent: Mrs M Armitage
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 25805
Received: 24/03/2021
Respondent: Stuart Bell
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 25834
Received: 24/03/2021
Respondent: Jackie Cooper
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 25863
Received: 24/03/2021
Respondent: Elizabeth Archer
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 25892
Received: 24/03/2021
Respondent: Jill Buckley
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 25921
Received: 24/03/2021
Respondent: Andy Wheeler
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 25950
Received: 24/03/2021
Respondent: Christine Hardaker
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 25979
Received: 24/03/2021
Respondent: Norah and David Jackman
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 26008
Received: 24/03/2021
Respondent: Tom Chatwyn
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 26037
Received: 24/03/2021
Respondent: Katherine Elston
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 26066
Received: 24/03/2021
Respondent: Peter Whiffin
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 26095
Received: 24/03/2021
Respondent: Catherine MacIntosh-Dixon
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 26124
Received: 24/03/2021
Respondent: Philip Batty
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 26153
Received: 24/03/2021
Respondent: Sophie Lamb
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 26182
Received: 24/03/2021
Respondent: Emma and Anthony Reed
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 26211
Received: 24/03/2021
Respondent: Helen Haskins
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 26240
Received: 24/03/2021
Respondent: Mrs Janet Sage
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 26269
Received: 22/03/2021
Respondent: Mr Paul Grant
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 26299
Received: 22/03/2021
Respondent: Louise Grant
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 26334
Received: 24/03/2021
Respondent: Prof. Jonathan Pitches
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 26363
Received: 24/03/2021
Respondent: Catherine Flint
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 26576
Received: 24/03/2021
Respondent: Mr Bernard Poulter
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?
Object
Draft Bradford District Local Plan - Preferred Options (Regulation 18) February 2021
Representation ID: 26691
Received: 24/03/2021
Respondent: Mr Owen Sage
Concerns at the approach adopted in respect of affordable housing policy have been expressed at Q4. In addition it is a surprise that despite a wealth of evidence in the Local Plan that should be used as input, it has clearly had little or no consideration e.g. looking at the suggested targets used in HO5, there are issues affecting the credibility of the figures in Zones 3 and 4.
Affordable home payment contributions by a developer can be made instead of delivering affordable housing on a development site. If BDMC have a genuine commitment to deliver affordable housing across the District, why is this even considered in the Local Plan? What is the justification or basis for this policy when affordable housing is needed in all areas of development?