Consultation Question 119

Object

Representation ID: 23424

Received: 23/03/2021

Respondent: Miss N Bateson

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 23453

Received: 23/03/2021

Respondent: Martin Tyson

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 23628

Received: 22/03/2021

Respondent: Sandra Auty

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 24140

Received: 23/03/2021

Respondent: Mr David and Elise Howe

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 24184

Received: 23/03/2021

Respondent: Helen Stocker

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 24223

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Ellie Keighley

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 24336

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Mr Benjamin Statham

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 24365

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Katrina Kennedy

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 24394

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Stephen Corbett

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 24423

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: James Stocker

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 24454

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Mrs Janine Ward

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 24483

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Catherine Hinchliffe

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 24568

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Lyndsey Lloyd

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 24597

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Steven Langford

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 24646

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Michelle Schofield

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 24721

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Danny Schofield

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 24759

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Hamish Logan

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 24788

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Ashera Grande

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 24866

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Chris Knowles

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Comment

Representation ID: 24891

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: CEG Land Promotions Ltd

Agent: Lichfields

Whilst the allocation of BU1/H is fully supported, it is noted that the text within the pro-forma is inconsistent with the position reached by the Council in supporting the planning application and the extensive areas of common ground reached between CEG and CBMDC. They should be reviewed.
SEE ATTACHMENT FOR FURTHER DETAILS

On the basis that planning permission has been granted by the Secretary of State for up to 500 homes, and indeed Table A at paragraph 5.6.13 identifies the site as being allocated for 500 homes, there is no justification for the conclusion/summary section of the proforma to identify the site as delivering between 250 and 500 homes. It should simply refer to 500 homes, consistent with the other parts of the plan.

Object

Representation ID: 24953

Received: 22/03/2021

Respondent: Bridget Day

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 24982

Received: 22/03/2021

Respondent: Mr Rob Pawson

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 25011

Received: 22/03/2021

Respondent: Anil Mander

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 25041

Received: 22/03/2021

Respondent: Louise Judd

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 25071

Received: 22/03/2021

Respondent: Richard Watson

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 25105

Received: 22/03/2021

Respondent: Tina Collins

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 25156

Received: 23/03/2021

Respondent: Donna Radcliffe

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 25210

Received: 23/03/2021

Respondent: Stephen Radcliffe

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 25239

Received: 23/03/2021

Respondent: Denise Stanford

BU1/H With this development Burley-in-Wharfedale has now fulfilled the housing obligation in the Core Strategy apart from 10 homes.

We note that the housing requirement has reduced to 625 i.e. an increase in target from 700 to 750 homes. Why has Burley an extra allocation when many other urban areas have a fall?

BU2/H The additional homes here would mean that Burley exceeds its housing allocation. Other areas of the District have yet to fulfil 50% of their allocation, much of which is brownfield, the priority according to the Local Plan.
The opposition to the Scalebor development is well founded on the grounds of sustainability [Q118; NPPF s2:7-14]. There are no exceptional circumstances that could justify development on this site.

For both sites, residents are concerned about the viability of affordable/social housing.

Object

Representation ID: 25314

Received: 23/03/2021

Respondent: Jeffrey Rothery

Agent: ID Planning

Consider that Land at Hag Farm, Burley in Wharfedale should be allocated for mixed development consisting of:

• Woodland (circa 1ha) – would be habitat creation, biodiversity opportunities and ecological connectivity benefits;

• Wharfedale Greenway – new footpath would connect this proposed route;

• Car parking for the railway station (26 spaces) – would assist in alleviating identified parking pressures;

• Re-location of a Builders Yard – would improve existing highways situation and ensures long term retention of the yard; and

• 2 residential dwellings – would provide a level of housing which respects the scale of the village and local housing needs. Will facilitate the provision of the remainder of the site to the Parish without cost.

Mix of uses will deliver significant ecological, social and community and highway benefits.

Proposal would seek to deliver aspirations, objectives and policies set out in the made Neighbourhood Plan.

Considered that exceptional circumstances exist to support the site’s allocation.