Consultation Question 42

Support

Representation ID: 26989

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Tim Price

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 27021

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Rosie Eccles

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 27050

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Clare Butland

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 27079

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Nabil Basharat

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 27132

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Ian Sunderland

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 27161

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Marianne Clarke

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 27190

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Carole Wheeler

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 27219

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Julie Sunderland

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 27248

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Gary Scott

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 27280

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Ms Jane Schofield

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 27309

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Mr Alan Lovell

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 27338

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Marjorie Rogan

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 27367

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Paul Cryer

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 27396

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Wendy Barton

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 27425

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Mr Richard Bardsley

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 27454

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Paul Warren

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 27576

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Danny Thompson

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 27701

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Peter Cartwright

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 27735

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Mrs Ann Todd

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 27808

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Richard Briggs

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 27839

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Claire Shouler

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 27903

Received: 23/03/2021

Respondent: Samantha Armitage

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 28202

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Sarah Lucas

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 28292

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: Stephen Mould

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Comment

Representation ID: 28999

Received: 24/03/2021

Respondent: National Trust

NT is generally supportive of this policy, in particular “to proactively preserve, protect and enhance the character, appearance, archaeological and historic value and significance of the District’s designated and undesignated heritage assets and their settings.” We are also supportive of point C to “require that all proposals for development conserve and where appropriate, enhance the heritage significance and setting of Bradford’s heritage assets (…).”

However, we are concerned that EN4 does not provide sufficient guidance that heritage decisions will be taken in accordance with national policy contained in the NPPF. Whilst the policy is sufficiently proactive and contains a positive suite of policies for the enhancement of heritage assets in the district, we consider the policy should contain direction on how harm to the significance of heritage assets will be assessed by the Council.

Support

Representation ID: 29019

Received: 23/04/2021

Respondent: Abi Lafbery

•We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms.

Support

Representation ID: 29073

Received: 29/03/2021

Respondent: Historic England

We support 4.28.1 - 4.28.5 which sets out a good outline of the considerable wealth of heritage assets of the District, the contribution which they make towards the distinctive character of Bradford, to its economic well-being, and to the quality of life of its communities, together with some of the challenges these assets are likely to face in the future.
We support 4.28.7 - 4.28.9 which sets out a good summary of the significance of Saltaire. We particularly welcome the requirement that development proposals should have regard to the World Heritage Site Management Plan, the World Heritage Site Environmental Capacity study and the Saltaire Conservation Area Appraisal.

Object

Representation ID: 29074

Received: 29/03/2021

Respondent: Historic England

Historic England’s Local Authority Profile for Bradford
District (2020) indicates a different number of
designated heritage assets to those listed under paragraph 4.28.10. Amend the list of designated heritage assets as follows:
 Saltaire World Heritage Site
 2,293 listed buildings, including 23 Grade I
and 69 Grade II*
 59 Conservation Areas
 15 Historic Parks and Gardens
 195 Scheduled Monuments
 Historic Battlefield Site at Adwalton Moor, Tong

The meaning of the final sentence to paragraph 4.28.16 is not clear at all. - Amend accordingly.

Policy EN4, C, amend to: ‘Require that all proposals for development conserve and where appropriate, enhance the heritage significance and setting of Bradford's heritage assets.’
E, amend to: ‘E. The alteration, extension or substantial demolition of a listed building will only be permitted if it can be demonstrated that the proposal:
1. Would not have any adverse effect upon the special architectural or historic interest of the building or its setting;
2. Is appropriate in terms of design, scale, detailing and materials; and
3. Would minimise the loss of historic fabric of the building.
or
4. If there is harm to the special interest of the building, that this is outweighed by the public benefits of the proposal.’

Support

Representation ID: 29225

Received: 23/03/2021

Respondent: Rachel Wood

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.

Support

Representation ID: 29578

Received: 23/03/2021

Respondent: Harvey Bosomworth

We support a policy which proactively preserves, protects and enhances our historic environment. In the case of Burley-in-Wharfedale, we agree that the significant views of, in our case, our semi-rural village’s iconic views, should be properly identified and protected (A4). We broadly support the aims outlined in EN4, but note that the medium and small sized villages are only mentioned in general terms. It may perhaps be necessary, to provide more detailed and specific policy for each settlement by working with residents and their Town and Parish Councils? Cooperation between those Town and Parish Councils, community groups and BMDC is crucial in defining where responsibility lies for protection of these assets and also where support from District Council is appropriate and required.